Christopher Poole, the founder of controversial online image board 4chan, outlined his vision for Web-based community today at the South by Southwest Interactive conference &8212' and yes, his ideas are in pretty sharp contrast to those of Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg.
Zuckerberg has spent a lot of time talking about his stance on identity and privacy, especially recently, as Facebook has taken more criticism for its various privacy policies. (To get the flavor of his remarks, check out VentureBeat&'s post about Zuckerberg&'s privacy stance from last May, as well as David Kirkpatrick&'s book The Facebook Effect.) He&'s been pretty aggressive about advocating for users to have one identity wherever they are online, because that encourages them to be more authentic (and also means they can carry their social connections with them to any site).
Poole, who is also known under his 4chan username &''moot&'', said, &''I think that&'s totally wrong.&'' He&'s had plenty of opportunity to observe the pluses and minuses of anonymity in action, since 4chan is well-known for its anonymous user base. (In fact, the activist hacker group that emerged from 4chan is known as Anonymous.)
Poole argued that anonymity allows users to reveal themselves in a &''completely unvarnished, unfiltered, raw way.&'' One of the things that&'s lost when you carry the same identity everywhere is &''the innocence of youth.&'' (&''Innocence&'' isn&'t the first word that would come to mind when I think of 4chan, but okay, I&'ll go with him here.) In other words, when everyone knows everything you&'ve done online, you&'re a lot more worried about screwing up, and you&'re less willing to experiment. Poole compared this to being a kid, moving to a new neighborhood, and having the opportunity to start over. On the Internet, you don&'t get that opportunity.
&''The cost of failure is really high when youa4a4re contributing as yourself,&'' Poole said.
In the case of 4chan, users feel a lot more comfortable trying to create funny images that can become memes, because content that doesn&'t catch on disappears quickly, and they&'re not weighed down by their failures. Poole said another benefit to 4chan&'s anonymity is that content becomes more important than the creator, which is unlike virtually any other online community. Rather than prioritizing the most valued and experienced users, 4chan allows anyone to access the site and post something that might take off.
At the same time, it seems Poole&'s attitude towards privacy has evolved. He&'s working on a new community site called Canv.as, which actually integrates with Facebook Connect, although users can still post anonymously. Poole said the fact that &''you know that we know&'' the user&'s real identity, even if other users can&'t see it, discourages people from indulging in the most obnoxious behavior.
The &''Wild West&'' approach, while important for 4chan&'s popularity, has had an effect on Poole&'s ability to turn the site into a real business. Very few brands are willing to run their ads alongside content that&'s so unpredictable and potentially offensive, he acknowledged.
Next Story: Apple exec confirms white iPhone coming this spring Previous Story: Google Earth aerial photos show extent of quake damage
Print Email Twitter Facebook Google Buzz LinkedIn Digg StumbleUpon Reddit Delicious Google More&8230'
Companies: 4chan, Canv.as, Facebook
People: Christopher Poole, Mark Zuckerberg, moot
Companies: 4chan, Canv.as, Facebook
People: Christopher Poole, Mark Zuckerberg, moot
Anthony is a senior editor at VentureBeat, as well as its reporter on media, advertising, and social networks. Before joining the site in 2008, Anthony worked at the Hollister Free Lance, where he won awards from the California Newspaper Publishers Association for breaking news coverage and writing. He attended Stanford University and now lives in San Francisco. Reach him at anthony@venturebeat.com. (All story pitches should also be sent to tips@venturebeat.com) You can also follow Anthony on Twitter.
Have news to share Launching a startup Email: tips@venturebeat.com
VentureBeat has new weekly email newsletters. Stay on top of the news, and don't miss a beat.
Discuss Add this link to... Bury
Comments